In the fast-paced world of startups, access to funding is often the difference between scaling and stalling. Among the many financing instruments available, convertible loans (also called convertible notes or convertible debt) have become especially popular for early-stage companies. They provide founders with quick access to capital while giving investors the option to convert their debt into equity at a later date, often during a future-priced funding round.

But while convertible loans are flexible for fundraising, they also pose unique challenges from an accounting and financial reporting perspective. Startups and their finance teams must carefully analyze these instruments to ensure accurate treatment under U.S. GAAP or IFRS, avoid misstatements, and remain audit ready.

What Is a Convertible Loan?

A convertible loan is essentially a debt instrument with an embedded equity conversion feature. Investors provide cash to the startup in the form of a loan, which accrues interest like traditional debt. Instead of repayment in cash, the loan can later be converted into shares of the company at a discount or subject to a valuation cap.

Key features typically include:

1. Principal and Interest: Usually accrues at a modest rate (e.g., 4–8%).
2. Conversion Option: The right to convert into equity at a discount to the next financing round.
3. Valuation Cap: Protects investors by capping the company’s maximum valuation for conversion.
4. Maturity Date: Often 12–24 months, with repayment due if no equity financing occurs.

Accounting Challenges

The dual nature of convertible loan debt with potential equity characteristics creates complexity in accounting. Treatment varies depending on jurisdiction and accounting framework, but the core issues include:

1. Classification: Is the instrument debt, equity, or a hybrid (compound financial instrument)?
2. Embedded Derivatives: Does the conversion feature meet the definition of a derivative that must be separated and measured at fair value?
3. Measurement: How should interest be recognized, and how is conversion accounted for when it occurs?

Accounting Under IFRS

Under IFRS (IAS 32 and IFRS 9):

1. If the conversion option gives the investor a fixed number of shares for a fixed amount of debt, it is usually classified as equity.
2. If conversion terms are variable (e.g., conversion at a discount or subject to a valuation cap), the option is often a derivative liability, requiring separate recognition and measurement at fair value through profit or loss (FVTPL).
3. The host loan component is measured at amortized cost using the effective interest method.

Conversion Event: When conversion occurs, the carrying amount of the debt and any related derivative is reclassified to equity, with no gain or loss recognized.

Example 1 – Fixed Conversion Price (Straightforward Case)

A startup borrows $500,000. The agreement says the investor can convert that loan into 50,000 shares at $10 per share.

Because the deal is clear and fixed (a set price and a set number of shares), accountants treat it mostly like normal debt plus an equity option.

1. The loan sits on the balance sheet as a liability.
2. Interest builds up over time.
3. When the investor converts, the company simply moves the loan balance into equity.

Example 2 – Valuation Cap or Discount (Common Startup Case)

A startup raises $1 million with a note that says the investor can convert at a 20% discount to the next funding round, or at a maximum valuation of $10 million.

Because the number of shares is not known in advance (it depends on a future funding price), accountants can’t treat this as simple equity.

1. Part of the loan is treated as regular debt.
2. The “conversion feature” (discount/valuation cap) is treated like a financial instrument whose value changes over time.
3. Every reporting period, the company must revalue that piece, which can increase or decrease depending on the company’s growth.

Why tricky? The loan could convert into very different amounts of equity depending on the future valuation.

Accounting Under U.S. GAAP

Under U.S. GAAP (ASC 470, ASC 480, and ASC 815):

1. Startups must first determine if the convertible loan is debt or equity under the “beneficial conversion feature (BCF)” guidance.
2. If there is a beneficial conversion feature (conversion price below fair value of stock at issuance), this must be separately recognized as additional paid-in capital (APIC) and reduce the carrying amount of the debt.
3. If the conversion option qualifies as a derivative, it must be bifurcated and accounted for at fair value.
4. Interest expense is recorded over time, and upon conversion, the debt is derecognized, and shares are issued.

Example 3 – Beneficial Conversion (Good Deal for Investor)

A startup takes a $200,000 loan that can be converted into shares at $1.00 each, but the company’s shares are already worth $1.50 each at the time of the deal.

The investor is getting a built-in discount (a sweetener).

1. Accountants record part of the loan as equity right away (the value of that discount).
2. The rest stays as debt.
3. Over time, interest is recorded on the reduced loan balance.
4. When the investor converts, the loan disappears, and the company issues shares.

Example 4 – Variable Conversion Terms (Like a Moving Target)

A startup borrows $750,000 with the agreement: “You can convert at a 20% discount to the next funding round price.”

Since no one knows what that future price will be, accountants treat the discount clause like a separate liability that moves with the market.

1. Loan is recorded as normal debt.
2. The discount/option is recorded separately and remeasured every period.
3. When conversion happens, both balances are cleared and moved into equity.

Why complex? Because the number of shares is unknown, the company must revalue the option regularly, which can cause swings in reported profit/loss.

Practical Considerations for Startups

1. Early Assessment: Consult accounting advisors before signing the loan agreement, terms like valuation caps can significantly change accounting treatment.
2. Investor Communication: Be transparent about how convertible loans affect the balance sheet and future dilution.
3. Audit Preparedness: Maintain supporting documentation for valuation of embedded derivatives and interest calculations.
4. Cash Flow Planning: Although conversion is common, startups should be prepared for the possibility of repayment if no qualifying financing occurs.
5. Cap Table Impact: Understand the eventual equity dilution impact and model conversion scenarios for board and investor discussions.

Why It Matters

Improper accounting of convertible loans can lead to material misstatements, restatements during fundraising or audits, and loss of investor trust. Startups that adopt the right accounting treatment not only ensure compliance but also provide clearer financial insights for decision-making and scaling.

How Professional Accounting Support Helps

Unlock Your Financial Potential with a Free Consultation.

At our firm, we understand that managing the complexities of audit, tax, technical accounting, and advisory services can be a significant undertaking for any business. In addition, we specialize in helping international entrepreneurs navigate U.S. company formation, tax compliance, and growth planning, making the process smooth, fast, and stress-free. That's why we're dedicated to providing not just expertise, but also a supportive partnership to help you navigate these critical areas. We're currently offering a complimentary, no-obligation consultation to discuss your unique financial landscape. This is a perfect opportunity to explore how our tailored strategies can enhance your financial health, ensure compliance, and drive sustainable growth. We invite you to contact us and discover how our collaborative approach can benefit your business.